Next Post
Banoffee + Nutella Greek Yogurt Waffle Cone Parfaits with Cashew Caramel Popcorn.
This post may contain affiliate links, please see our privacy policy for details.
And I really do mean secret.

Or at least it was before today anyway, but it’s time to share this recipe.
We’d be selfish if we didn’t. And I say we because I asked Mrs. Mooney about sharing this recipe way back when I started the blog. Not sure why I took so long to share it, but here it is. Just in time for Mardi Gras too!

I know I have talked about Mrs. Mooney before, but this is one of her tried and true recipes that is truly and utterly amazing. Every single time I make this gumbo my family says, over and over again, how good it is.
The reason this recipe is a secret? Well… sorry, that has to remain a secret, but at least you get the recipe.

I cannot actually remember the first time I tried Mrs. Mooney’s gumbo, but I sure do remember the first time I ever made it.
I was pretty young, maybe fourteen or fifteen and I was so nervous. I remember having no idea what a roux was and I was totally freaking out that if I burned it, I would then have to start all over again. Not only that, I actually had to sit and stir the roux for forty-five minutes and not walk away. Like not even take my eyes off the pot for more than fifteen seconds at a time. Yeah, I was scared.

I still remember sending photos of the roux throughout out the process to Mrs. Mooney, just to make sure things where looking good and I was not screwing everything up. Just about every other minute I thought I had burned the roux and needed to start over.
And geez, when I finally got the roux to the color needed and I added the veggies? Yikes. Everything bubbled up and made noise. Loud sizzling noises. I thought for sure I screwed it up there too, but it turns out that is totally normal.
FYI, Mrs Mooney spent practically the entire hour or so it took me to make this on the phone with me talking me through every step. I may not have ever gone to cooking school, but at least I have Mrs. Mooney, and really, that’s better. If you knew her, you would agree.

Long story short, the gumbo got made, turned out better than I ever thought it could and in five years of making her gumbo I have yet to burn the roux. YES.
Although, I still get a little nervous every time I make the gumbo. Old habits die hard.
If you are wondering, a roux is flour and butter, bacon fat and flour or in this case, oil and flour. You mix together the flour and oil and cook it over the stove to help thicken and flavor things like sauces, soups and stews. If you have ever made mac and cheese than you have made a roux.

As Mrs. Mooney says, “The roux is the heart and soul of this recipe. If you burn it, start over and do not take your eyes off of it.”
I know it may sound scary, but it is honestly a super easy recipe and I scaled her original recipe down by half because the original recipe literally fed like sixteen people, so the roux took more like forty-five to sixty minutes to cook. This one will take thirty minutes tops because there is less to cook.

Here is my little tip. Grab a stool, turn the TV on if you can or grab your phone. Then glue your butt to that seat right in front of the stove. Seriously, I am not messing around when I say that you have to whisk the roux every fifteen to twenty-five seconds. It is mandatory.
You know the roux is done when it turns a deep dark caramel or peanut butter color. I let mine go pretty dark because I think the darker the better, but just make sure you are not burning it.
Oh, and it is also mandatory to have all your ingredient prepped and ready to go before you start making the roux. Trust me, it helps so much.

Okay, with all that said, please do not get scared off. I promise this recipe is very easy and simple to make. Once the roux is made all you need to do is let the gumbo simmer for a few hours. I let mine cook low and slow all day long. The longer it cooks, the better the flavor.
You must serve this over rice because rice is just the best, it is also very traditional. Beer bread is also delicious with it, but technically not traditional. BUT – you would be a little crazy not to serve it with some bread. Just sayin.

Nutritional information is only an estimate. The accuracy of the nutritional information for any recipe on this site is not guaranteed.

Oh and gumbo kicks Monday in the butt.
HEY GUYS, I NEED YOUR HELP!!
Better Homes and Gardens has nominated Half Baked Harvest as one of the top 5 Food: Family/Everyday Eats blogs. Between now and March 5 voting will take place to decide who is number one. Here’s the catch, you can vote every HOUR until 3/5/14. I would be so appreciative if you could take the time to check out all the bloggers and vote for your favorite… as often as you can between now and then. Thanks for all your support, you guys are why I love doing what I do! VOTE HERE
SO glad you shared this secret recipe because it looks insanely good! Beer bread seems very, very necessary as well.
Beer bread is a must! 🙂
Thanks Beth!
this looks so yummy! perfect timing with mardi gras on the way =)
Thank you!
That gravy looks like absolute perfection!
Thanks Jen!
This looks SOOO good!! I’ve never made gumbo before and that is definitly going to change!!!
Thanks Helen! Hope you love it!
As someone who has made many pots of gumbo, yes, you’ve got to continually stir the roux until it gets to that peanut butter/dark caramel color. As the oil and flour brown, you’ve got the scrape the browned parts from the bottom of the pot, so constant stirring is a must. It’s a little bit of work..but SO worth it.
So worth it! 🙂
Tieghan, my mouth is watering! This looks delicious. Awesome photos.
Thank you so much, Bri!
Looks awesome Tieghan! And I love all these photos. Also, didn’t comment on your last post, but I am in Cleveland OH now! Can’t believe you used to live there! And Malley’s chocolates? We are all over those! We’ve bought so much from there I’ve lost count haha!
Haha! No way! What area do you live in?
Looks Tasty!
Thank Kevin!
This looks so incredible and I bet your house smelled wonderful! And a big congrats on the nomination! That’s so fabulous!
Thanks Brain and yes, the smell it so good!
This gumbo looks like the real deal. This one is going on the menu for this weekend. My husband is going to love you forever. Pinned and shared. Oh, and I voted. Good luck, Tieghan. Thanks for not keeping this beauty a secret.
Thanks so much and for voting as well! 🙂
Looks so good Tieghan – reminds me of our family’s visit to New Orleans years ago when a local family hosted our entire little league baseball team for gumbo and etouffee. Good luck with your contest – just voted!
Thank you so much, Jeanette! Sounds like a fun visit!
Adding to my dinner menu this week! Mmm!
Let me know if you end up making it. Hope you guys love it!
Thanks Jenny!
This looks soo good. I have never even tried gumbo but this looks pretty easy!
Thanks Kathy! Hope you get to give it a try!
YUM! My hubby and I first tried gumbo when we drove through New Orleans on our move down to Florida, and we both fell in kuurrve! I have never known how to make it, so this recipe is perfecto.
I mean, like all your recipes. 🙂
Love the lighting in these pics!
Thanks Taylor! I hope you get to make this!
Looks sooo appetizing, Tieghan … even at 10am! I wonder if this could be done in a crockpot as it needs so long to cook? After making the roux, of course! And do you mean literally stir the flour and oil for 30 minutes at the beginning, or did I miss something?
You do have to stir it for 30 minutes, but I promise it is worth it!
Hope you love this and thanks Helen!